RB Tiers and Rankings (Top 75 Post-Draft)

RB Tiers and Rankings (Top 75 Post-Draft)

The rankings below are based on full-PPR scoring, and will be updated regularly throughout spring and summer. They won't necessarily align with the RotoWire cheatsheets or projections, though I did use those tools as a guide to get started.

(Rankings updated September 2)

Tier 1

1. Christian McCaffrey

2. Saquon Barkley

These guys play on all three downs and have proven themselves efficient as both ballcarriers and pass catchers. They also have lousy backups, so any loss of carries figures to be limited to garbage time or the need for an occasional breather.

Tier 2

3. Ezekiel Elliott

4. Alvin Kamara

Zeke has a talented backup looking over his shoulder, but he also has the security of playing in a top-10 offense, which means the fifth-year pro can afford to lose a few touches from his career average of 23.4 per game (22.2 last season). Kamara over teammate Michael Thomas is an easy choice for me at No. 4 overall, given positional scarcity and the likelihood of the former seeing positive regression in terms of both TDs per touch and yards per catch.

Tier 3

5. Derrick Henry

6. Joe Mixon

7. Clyde Edwards-Helaire

8. Kenyan Drake

9. Austin Ekeler

10. Dalvin Cook

This is probably the lowest you'll see anyone rank Cook, who was awesome last season and decided not to hold out from training camp. I still worry that the Vikings will cut back his workload a little bit as a concession to the contract situation, but

The rankings below are based on full-PPR scoring, and will be updated regularly throughout spring and summer. They won't necessarily align with the RotoWire cheatsheets or projections, though I did use those tools as a guide to get started.

(Rankings updated September 2)

Tier 1

1. Christian McCaffrey

2. Saquon Barkley

These guys play on all three downs and have proven themselves efficient as both ballcarriers and pass catchers. They also have lousy backups, so any loss of carries figures to be limited to garbage time or the need for an occasional breather.

Tier 2

3. Ezekiel Elliott

4. Alvin Kamara

Zeke has a talented backup looking over his shoulder, but he also has the security of playing in a top-10 offense, which means the fifth-year pro can afford to lose a few touches from his career average of 23.4 per game (22.2 last season). Kamara over teammate Michael Thomas is an easy choice for me at No. 4 overall, given positional scarcity and the likelihood of the former seeing positive regression in terms of both TDs per touch and yards per catch.

Tier 3

5. Derrick Henry

6. Joe Mixon

7. Clyde Edwards-Helaire

8. Kenyan Drake

9. Austin Ekeler

10. Dalvin Cook

This is probably the lowest you'll see anyone rank Cook, who was awesome last season and decided not to hold out from training camp. I still worry that the Vikings will cut back his workload a little bit as a concession to the contract situation, but my bigger concern is his growing history of shoulder injuries. Then there's the matter of the Vikings rebuilding their secondary, which could lead to a weaker defense and fewer run-heavy game scripts.

Tier 4

11. Miles Sanders  

12. Nick Chubb

13. Josh Jacobs

14. Aaron Jones

15. James Conner

Conner and Jones have more upside for receiving involvement, while Chubb and Jacobs are elite runners with tougher competition for snaps. Life would be more fun if the Browns didn't have Kareem Hunt and the Raiders didn't like Jalen Richard so much.

Tier 5

16. Devin Singletary

17. Melvin Gordon

18. Chris Carson

19. Todd Gurley

20. Jonathan Taylor

21. Le'Veon Bell

I'd be fine starting any of these guys as an RB2 in Week 1, but I think they'll all be disappointing if you expect the production of past years (Taylor and Singletary aside). I'm sure one of the bunch will prove me wrong and tear it up; I just don't have any idea which one it will be.

Tier 6

22. D'Andre Swift

23. Raheem Mostert

24. Cam Akers

25. David Johnson

26. Ronald Jones

27. James White

Tier 7

28.  Mark Ingram

29. Tarik Cohen

30. Kareem Hunt

31. David Montgomery

32. J.K. Dobbins

33. Matt Breida

34. Phillip Lindsay

35. Duke Johnson

36. Tevin Coleman

37. Kerryon Johnson

38. Jordan Howard

There guys are something more than handcuffs but something less than reliable starters. While stand-alone value is possible, you're probably dreaming of the teammate-injury scenario when you draft them in the middle rounds. Cohen is an exception, but his secure pass-catching volume comes at the cost of minimal rushing upside.

I expect to see a pretty even split between the two guys in Miami, and I won't be shocked if a Patrick Laird or Myles Gaskin also steals some touches. The Dolphins look much better than they did at the same time last year, but they still have a bottom-five roster.

Tier 8

39. Latavius Murray

40. Tony Pollard

41. Zack Moss

42. Chase Edmonds

43. Boston Scott

44. Alexander Mattison

45. Antonio Gibson

Here we have high-end handcuffs, which is kind of an oxymoron. Edmonds might seem like an odd inclusion, until you look at the Arizona depth chart behind him. Mattison is the one getting all the attention; I just worry that he'll form a committee with Mike Boone and Ameer Abdullah if Cook ends up missing games.

Tier 9

46. Ryquell Armstead

47. Damien Harris

48. Adrian Peterson

49. Leonard Fournette

50. Marlon Mack

51. Darrell Henderson

52. Darrel Williams

53. Sony Michel

54. Justin Jackson

55. Joshua Kelley

Henderson looked a lot better before the Rams drafted Akers in the second round. Jackson and Kelley are competing for a role that probably isn't especially valuable. Mack would be best served by a trade.

Tier 10

56. Chris Thompson

57. Benny Snell

58. Darrynton Evans

59. AJ Dillon

60. Giovani Bernard

61. Ke'Shawn Vaughn

62. Nyheim Hines

63. Carlos Hyde

64. Jerick McKinnon

65. Brian Hill

66. Mike Boone

67. Ito Smith

68. Anthony McFarland

69. Jamaal Williams

70. Rashaad Penny

71. DeAndre Washington

72. Malcolm Brown

73. Lamical Perine

74. Jalen Richard

75. Mike Davis

Want to Read More?
Subscribe to RotoWire to see the full article.

We reserve some of our best content for our paid subscribers. Plus, if you choose to subscribe you can discuss this article with the author and the rest of the RotoWire community.

Get Instant Access To This Article Get Access To This Article
RotoWire Community
Join Our Subscriber-Only NFL Chat
Chat with our writers and other RotoWire NFL fans for all the pre-game info and in-game banter.
Join The Discussion
ABOUT THE AUTHOR
Jerry Donabedian
Jerry was a 2018 finalist for the FSWA's Player Notes Writer of the Year and DFS Writer of the Year awards. A Baltimore native, Jerry roots for the Ravens and watches "The Wire" in his spare time.
Ryan Grubb and the History of College Coaches Headed to the NFL
Ryan Grubb and the History of College Coaches Headed to the NFL
10 Sneaky Tricks For Your Upcoming Rookie Draft (Video)
10 Sneaky Tricks For Your Upcoming Rookie Draft (Video)
NFL Draft Decisions: Navigating Make-or-Break Moments
NFL Draft Decisions: Navigating Make-or-Break Moments
Dynasty Startup Draft LIVE! Superflex; ROOKIES Included! (Video)
Dynasty Startup Draft LIVE! Superflex; ROOKIES Included! (Video)